Paying the price… for what?

Broken olive trees in the southern Hebron hills, 24 July 2012. Settler violence against Palestinians and their property has risen by 150% each year since 2008.

There’s a phrase that’s become common parlance among a number of extremist Jewish settlers in the West Bank. It gets sprayed on mosques, schools and homes following acts of violence and vandalism against Palestinians: “Price tag.”

The slogan has been adopted by settlers who’ve vowed to avenge any removal of illegal settlements by the Israeli government.

Today it was sprayed on a rock above a Palestinian-owned orchard close to the Jewish settlements of Avigayll and Ma’on, in the remote southern Hebron hills. Sprawled out below, their limbs snapped and twisted into the sky, were 44 vandalised olive trees.

“Price tag – for what? For forty years of occupation? It makes no sense,” says Abed NaMohammad, who lives in the nearby village of Yatta.

‘Price tag’ attacks cost Palestinians dearly. In recent years the campaign has seen mosques burned, property destroyed and communities intimidated with hateful graffiti. In some cases, the violence is so intense that Palestinians are forced to leave their homes and move towards larger urban areas of the West Bank for safety.

But for settlers, the campaign comes with almost no price tag whatsoever.

‘Price tag’ graffiti, southern Hebron hills, 24 July 2012.

This month the UN reported that the number of attacks by Israeli settlers against Palestinians and their property has risen by about 150 percent each year since 2008, with 154 attacks in the first half of this year alone.

At a press conference organized by UNICEF, the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, the Ecumenical Accompaniment Programme in Palestine and Israel ‏(EAPPI‏), and the human rights groups B’Tselem and Al-Haq, international journalists were told that the Israeli authorities are failing to respond to mounting settler violence against Palestinians.

Over 90% of complaints regarding settler violence monitored by the UN in recent years have been closed without indictment.

According to Nasser a-Nawaj’a, who lives in the nearby village of Susiya, the two men who own the wrecked olive trees are unlikely to bother raising a complaint with the Israeli authorities, because they know nothing will come of it.

As Leah Levane, my EAPPI colleague and a board member of Jews for Justice for Palestinians, put it as she looked at the rows of broken trees: “It doesn’t matter what the Bible says about your right to the land. There’s no excuse for this.”



Filed under Hebron

2 responses to “Paying the price… for what?

  1. Hey Chris, great stuff. But, if you focus on Hebron, why didn’t you write about the Arab price tag – how they almost killed Ron last week, throwing a boulder on his, opening up his head, at the spring in Hebron? Take a look – – also here’s a link to photos – worse than olive trees, no?
    David Wilder, Hebron

    • chrisjamescox

      Thanks David, I appreciate your comments. That incident on Tel Rumeida was, of course, appalling – I hope that Ron makes a swift and full recovery – and I will be mentioning in a blog that I’ll be publishing shortly. But I think the overall point in my original article remains intact: as the UN and other bodies have noted, there is a systemic failure by the Israeli authorities in the West Bank to punish violence against Palestinians, which leaves the latter particularly vulnerable. Since this is not the case the other way around – Palestinian violence attracts the full force of Israeli military law, and I’ve not seen anyone argue that it goes unpunished – I feel that it remains important, particularly when writing for an international audience like mine, to highlight the enormous power imbalance between the two ‘sides’. What are your thoughts? Thanks again for your comments, and please do keep reading. Very best, Chris

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s